Under The Radar
|
|
|
|
SUPREME COURT
The Road Ahead
Today, the Senate is expected to affirm what was obvious the moment that President Obama introduced Judge Sonia Sotomayor to the American people: Sotomayor’s brilliant intellect, compelling life story, and 17-year record of fidelity to the law prepare her well for the Supreme Court. She will make an outstanding justice. Yet even as she ascends to the pinnacle of the legal profession, Sotomayor joins a Court controlled by conservatives loyal to an ideology that consistently places powerful interest groups ahead of the law.
STORMS ON THE HORIZON: Two major First Amendment cases await Sotomayor when she steps into her new chambers at the Supreme Court. The first is Citizens United v. FEC, a campaign finance case. Although Citizens United was originally scheduled to be decided this summer, the Court ominously ordered the parties to brief whether a landmark precedent limiting the influence of corporate money in politics should be overruled. Sotomayor’s record strongly suggests that she will support robust campaign finance regulation, but her five conservative colleagues appear poised to declare longstanding bans on corporate money in politics unconstitutional. Should the conservatives get their way inCitizens United, it could be the end of meaningful campaign finance regulation. Similarly, the Supreme Court has teed up an important church-state separation case that could free the Roy Moores of the world to fill America’s landscape with taxpayer-funded monuments to their personal religious beliefs. In Salazar v. Buono, the justices will consider whether a cross erected in the middle of a federal land preserve can be challenged under the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. For years, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor was the key fifth vote upholding the Constitution’s ban on government endorsements of religion. With her gone, it is likely that this ban will be whittled away into non-existence.
THE BACK BENCH: Although Obama found an exceptional nominee for the Supreme Court, future presidents’ ability to do so will depend on the judges Obama is able to confirm to the lower courts. Every single one of the Supreme Court’s current members was seasoned by his or her prior appointment to a lower federal court, and conservatives have long understood the need to appoint young, up-and-coming attorneys to the courts in order to create a deep bench of future Supreme Court nominees. So far, however, Obama has not charted the same course. The average age of his nominees is 55 – five years older, on average, than the men and women given lifetime appointments by President Bush. Most of the names on Bush’s “short list” of potential Surpeme Court nominees were nominated by President Reagan or President George H.W. Bush when they were in their 30s or early 40s. (Sotomayor was 37 when she was first appointed to the federal bench.) Moreover, the need to fill the courts with young lawyers who share Sotomayor’s brilliance and fidelity to the law is especially acute in light of the advantage right-wing judges currently hold on the federal bench. During the Clinton administration, then-Senate Judiciary Chair Orrin Hatch (R-UT)systematically kept President Clinton’s nominees off the bench by allowing a single home-state senator to veto a nominee. Wielding this authority,segregationist Republican senator Jesse Helms blocked every single one of Clinton’s nominees from North Carolina. When Bush came into office, however, this rule suddenly vanished. The result is a judiciary which conservatives will continue to dominate unless Obama is just as aggressive in appointing brilliant young lawyers to the federal bench as Bush was.
REPAIRING THE LAW: In just the past few years, the Court’s conservatives have consistently placed employers’ interests ahead of laws forbidding employment discrimination; they have ignored the plain meaning oflaws protecting the environment; and they have repeatedly seized opportunities toimmunize corporate interests from the law. Thankfully, there is no evidence that Sotomayor will join the Court’s conservatives in this crusade. But so long as the right-wing majority sits, Congress must carry the burden of pushing back against the Court’s worst decisions. This year’s Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act was a good start; and recently introduced bills that would overrule two Supreme Court decisions limiting ordinary Americans’ access to courts are also promising signs. Ultimately, however, Congress must be far more aggressive in order to undo the damage caused by decades of conservative decisions eating away at the lawsworkers, seniors, the environment and the insured depend on to protect them against discrimination, abuse and fraud. The American people elected this Congress to turn away from the Roberts Court’s right-wing values: It’s time for Congress to step up to the plate.
Related Posts - Obama will use summit to bring Cuba in from the cold President Barack Obama is poised to offer an olive branch to Cuba in an effort to repair the US's tattered reputation in Latin America. The White House has moved to ease some...
- Obama Defends Baucus Bill Yesterday, President Obama appeared on five Sunday morning talk shows, fielding questions that predominantly focused on health care, the war in Afghanistan, and race. Obama defended the Senate Finance Committee'sAmerica's Healthy Future...
- Will Obama have to be better because he's black? Just days before he was sworn in, President Obama was giving his daughters a tour of the Lincoln Memorial when one of them pointed to a copy of Abraham Lincoln's...
- Ways To Help Our Friends In Haiti's Tragedy Here is a compiled list of other ways to help from CTV News. Following is a list of links to Canadian organizations that have a track record of providing aid...
- Clinton, Bush Booked for Toronto Appearance Former U.S. presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush will appear together in Toronto next month on a public stage for the first time since Mr. Bush ended his presidency,...
- The campaign grinds onHillary Clinton has few weapons in hand to win the Democratic nomination for president“I THINK it would be a great thing if we had an election year...
Related Websites - Don't compare Obama to Bush [/caption] I find it quite odd these days how many pundits say that President Barack Obama is starting to sound the same as President George W. Bush. This is happening because of the recent troop allocations, timetables and other actions that the Obama administration undertook in support of our efforts......
- Obama says time for Iran to decide future path It is time for Iran to decide whether to focus on the past or open the door to greater opportunity, U.S. President Barack Obama said in a statement issued late on Tuesday. The statement, marking the 30th anniversary of the storming of the U.S. embassy in Tehran and the start......
- GOP Forces New House Vote on Health Care Bill [/caption] Republicans succeed in forcing a change in a measure altering Obama's newly enacted health care overhaul, meaning the bill will have to return to the House for final congressional approval. WASHINGTON -- Senate Republicans learned early Thursday that they will be able to kill language in a measure altering......
- DoD rape tragedy This is the saddest thing that the Obama administration has done. The US Department of Defense, the people that are supposed to be defending us, thinks that it is okay for rape to happen within their body via their contractors and the accused company be going away scott free. James......
- What Karl Rove got wrong on the U.S. deficit [/caption] By David Axelrod -reprinted from the Washington Post Rove has some impressive campaign victories to his credit. But given the shape in which the last administration left this country, I'm not sure I would solicit his advice. And given the backhanded advice he offered, I'm not sure he was......
- President Barack Obama. This is the America that I want other nations to know. The America that overcomes, that comes together, that takes part in their own democracy. For 8 long years our standing in the world has slowly fallen to levels not before seen - but no more. We the people spoke......
Short URL: http://www.internationalnetworknews.com/?p=2854



















